Skip to content
Recipe menu

Next time you make spaghetti sauce, stir two spoons of this into the pot and it tastes like it simmered all Sunday

A weeknight pot of spaghetti sauce can taste disappointingly flat, even after the tomatoes have simmered and the pasta is ready. What makes one quick batch taste so much richer than another?

spaghetti sauce simmered Sunday

The onions are soft and the crushed tomatoes are bubbling, but a taste from the spoon still leaves something missing. More salt may make the sauce saltier without giving it the rounded flavor a longer simmer can bring. A small addition can help, though the amount matters if the tomatoes are to remain the main flavor.

Fish sauce adds savory depth to tomato sauce

Fish sauce is the ingredient to stir into a quick spaghetti sauce when canned tomatoes taste flat. It adds glutamate, which gives the sauce a deeper savory flavor, along with salt that can make the tomatoes taste fuller. For a sauce made with 1 28-ounce (794 g) can of tomatoes, start with 1 tablespoon of fish sauce.

Add the fish sauce when the tomatoes go into the pot, then stir and let the sauce simmer. Adding it at this stage distributes its flavor throughout the sauce rather than leaving a salty taste in 1 spoonful. It can make a short-cooked sauce taste more rounded, but it cannot reproduce every flavor that develops during a long simmer.

Umami fills a gap that herbs cannot

Tomatoes bring acidity and some sweetness to spaghetti sauce, while garlic, onion and herbs add aroma. Those ingredients do not always provide enough savory depth, particularly when the sauce has little time to cook. Fish sauce adds glutamate, the compound associated with umami, as well as a subtle sweetness from fermentation.

Umami was identified as a distinct taste in 1908 by Japanese chemist Kikunae Ikeda, who studied the savory flavor of dashi broth. In tomato sauce, the useful distinction is practical: adding more herbs changes the aroma, while a small amount of fish sauce changes how savory the sauce tastes. Neither approach replaces tasting the sauce for salt.

Anchovies offer another way to build savory flavor

For a sauce made with 2 28-ounce (794 g) cans of tomatoes, use about 1 teaspoon of anchovy paste or 2 anchovy fillets instead of fish sauce. If using fillets, chop them finely or add them to the pot while sautéing garlic or onion, stirring until they soften before adding the tomatoes. Stir anchovy paste into the pot before the tomatoes, then simmer the sauce until it is hot.

Curing concentrates the anchovies’ natural glutamates, and the softened fillets blend into the sauce. At these small amounts, they add savory flavor rather than a prominent fish taste. More anchovy paste or fillets can make the sauce taste too salty or noticeably fishy, so taste before adding more.

Salt and acidity still need separate adjustments

Fish sauce and anchovies both contribute salt. If the finished sauce tastes too salty, adding sugar will not remove the salt; add more unsalted tomatoes to dilute it instead, and hold back other salty ingredients. One family recipe uses 1 tablespoon of fish sauce with 2 tablespoons of soy sauce in a batch of sauce, but that combination may be too salty for a different batch.

If the problem is sourness rather than salt, try ½ to 1 teaspoon of sugar per 28-ounce (794 g) can of tomatoes, then taste again. Sugar can soften the perception of acidity, but it does not lower the sauce’s pH. Fish sauce and anchovies are unsuitable for anyone avoiding fish; mushrooms or miso can be alternatives, though they will taste different. Check labels when avoiding gluten, since soy sauce and miso products vary.

For the next quick sauce, add fish sauce with the tomatoes, let the pot reach a simmer, and taste before reaching for extra salt or sugar.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *